It’s possible for a person to spend decades living at half capacity, and they might not even know it. They show up to work, to relationships, to dinner. And they perform. Not in the theatrical sense, but in the quiet, exhausting way of someone who has quietly decided that the real version of themselves is not safe to bring to the table. The mental overhead of managing that performance is enormous. And the costs to decision-making, to relationships, to the basic quality of a day, are ones most people never connect back to the root cause.

Andy Vargo spent 40 years managing exactly that performance. A Gen X man raised in a Catholic family in Tacoma, Washington, Vargo knew from an early age that he was attracted to men. He married his high school sweetheart at 21 and built a life that looked, from the outside, exactly as it was supposed to look. He came out at 40, married, with three teenage kids. The immediate aftermath was not the relief he might have expected. The relief came later. First came the wreckage.
If you’ve ever held something back about yourself, not necessarily something this significant but something, and felt the low-grade drain of carrying it, this conversation is worth your time. Vargo’s story is told with uncommon clarity and a complete absence of self-pity. It’s less about coming out and more about what happens to a person when they finally stop hiding. What he discovered about authenticity, decision-making, and the cost of self-concealment applies well beyond the specifics of his situation.
The Cost of a Hidden Identity Isn’t Just Emotional
Vargo is careful not to position his experience as categorically harder than anyone else’s. “We all have something,” he said. “I really believe we don’t know what everybody’s thing is.”
But the mechanics of what self-concealment does to a person are worth examining, because they are not unique to being closeted. They are the mechanics of any sustained performance.

For Vargo, the performance shaped every small decision. What to order for lunch. What music to mention. How to dress. “I would think about every step of the day,” he said. “How do I dress? Because I don’t want to look too stylish, because that’s going to look gay. What am I going to order for lunch if I go out with coworkers? I don’t want to get a salad, because that’s going to look gay.”
The cumulative weight of that surveillance is something he only quantified in retrospect. “I can’t even put a guesstimate on, was that 30% of my headspace? Was it 40%? Was it 60%? But it was a huge amount of my thoughts and headspace and being preoccupied with how I’m showing up. So that means that only leaves the rest for me to make a clear decision with. So I think I’m showing up 100% or 120% because it feels like I’m working so hard, and yet I really only have 60% effort or attention to devote.”
The performance shaped his relationships, too. Not just his marriage, but his professional life. He described a pattern of gravitating toward environments where he was a doormat, tolerating domineering bosses and a relationship dynamic that was, by his own assessment, toxic. “I found myself continually putting myself in relationships where I was kind of the doormat,” he said. “I wouldn’t stand up for myself.”
He traces it back to the same source. “When people don’t know what we’re struggling with or what we’re hiding, all they feel is there’s something shady going on or you have an ulterior motive. And because they know they can’t trust you because you’re hiding something.” The logic held even when inverted. Vargo tolerated bad treatment in part because, somewhere underneath, he believed he deserved it. “I always had that fear of, well, if I stand up for myself, then what am I left with?”
What the Transition Actually Looked Like
Coming out at 40 did not produce the Hollywood outcome. “When you mentioned the rainbows and unicorns popping out of the sky and balloons everywhere,” Vargo said, he was not exempt from the valley that follows any major life change.
He lost his job three weeks after coming out. Officially it was about territory management and performance, though three people were hired to replace him. His marriage ended. He moved out of the family home. He found himself alone in a rented room, asking a question that will be recognizable to anyone who has ever traded security for honesty: “What was all this for? What was the point of making all these major changes just over who you want to have sex with? Like, that seems, like, so unimportant compared to all of the things that were rocked in my life.”
The valley, as Vargo now understands it, was structural. He’d dismantled his entire support system before he had anything to replace it with. “Everything had been stripped away. That was my regular support system, my financial support. Everything had been gone. And yet I hadn’t started to refill the cup yet.”
He’s also reflective about how he handled the disclosure itself. Vargo did not come out to his wife in a moment of brave reckoning. He came out after a particularly good weekend, when he realized she believed things were improving and he had lost what he thought was his exit. “I thought I had a way out,” he said. “I thought we were done. I thought we were moving on.” And so he told her, framing it as a condition. If they were going to try to make this work, she needed to know. “That’s not the right way to stand up for yourself in a relationship or to declare what you want. I’m fully aware of that now. This is after a decade of work, by the way.”
That decade of work is worth noting. The clarity Vargo speaks with now is not the clarity of the moment. It’s the clarity of someone who did the subsequent processing.
Authenticity and the Mechanics of Decision-Making
Amy Stone asked Vargo directly: did making good decisions become easier with authenticity in his life?
“Oh, definitely, yes,” he said.
The mechanism is simpler than it might seem. When a significant portion of your mental bandwidth is occupied by managing a performance, the cognitive resources available for actual decisions are depleted before you get to them. Once that overhead drops, something shifts.
Vargo described it through something as mundane as being asked where he wanted to go for lunch. “I really struggle answering that question,” he said of his former self. “And now I’ll say, you know, pizza or Mexican or Chinese, I don’t care.” But more importantly, he can now distinguish between genuinely not caring and struggling to make a claim on what he actually wants. “Breaking down the difference between do I really not have a stake in the decision or do I struggle to make a claim on what it is that I care about. Those are two different things.”
The coping mechanisms built up over decades don’t disappear overnight. About a year after coming out, Vargo caught himself telling a friend that something was “going to make me look gay.” The friend’s response was simple: “But you are.” The reminder landed. “It isn’t a problem that I look that way because that’s who I am.”
He’s also deliberate about not letting a single aspect of his identity become the entire story. There are people who’ve known him for years who don’t know he’s gay. Not because he’s hiding it. Because it hasn’t come up. “We met as small business owners, or we met because they’re the barista at my coffee shop, and I go in there every day, and then one day they’re like, oh, I didn’t know that about you. And it’s not a big deal. It’s just. Yeah, because I was giving you my coffee order.”
Why He Tells This Story
Vargo is now a speaker and coach. The version of authenticity he teaches is deliberately accessible. He is not trying to convince anyone of anything about sexual identity. He’s trying to make the case that whatever you’re hiding, even something minor, is probably costing you more than you realize.
“If someone has been holding back on the fact that they love pineapple on pizza, and they haven’t wanted to voice that in the office because they know there are pineapple pizza haters around, they’re gonna be okay saying they like it,” he said. “That’s gonna open up the doors to not only repel the people who have that problem with me, but also attract the people who are gonna support that part of my life.”
Stone drew out the other side of the equation. When something about you is invisible and you don’t disclose it, the people around you can’t help you. “They can’t give you directions. They can’t. Nothing. They can’t. Nothing.” The practical cost of invisibility is not just loneliness. It’s the absence of support that would actually be available if people knew what they were dealing with.
Vargo’s central argument, distilled to its plainest form: hiding who you are creates distrust in others and in yourself. And the inverse is also true. Once you stop hiding, the relationships that remain are real ones. The decisions get cleaner. The energy that was devoted to management becomes available for something else.
“I can show up anywhere in life completely,” Vargo said, describing the life he has now, “if I’m honest with myself first.”
This article was inspired by an interview with Andy Vargo and Amy Stone on The Art of Imperfect Adulting podcast. https://imperfect-adulting.captivate.fm/listen or https://www.youtube.com/@imperfectadulting To hear more compelling conversations like this one and receive special offers from our guests directly to your inbox, join our email community today.
Identity: Interview transcript Andy Vargo with Amy Stone | The Art of Imperfect Adulting | July 2026
Amy Stone [00:00:01]:
You’re listening to the Art of Imperfect Adulting. I’m your host, Amy Stone. Here I share stories from real people navigating the adventure that I call adulting. Are you ready? Me too. Let’s do this. Well, hello, friends. My guest today is Andy Vargo. Andy, are you ready for a fun chat today?
Andy Vargo [00:00:26]:
I am super excited for fun chat today.
Amy Stone [00:00:28]:
Yay. I am, too.
Amy Stone [00:00:30]:
I always start my conversations with the same first question. What part of the world do you call home? And then there’s a follow up, which is, what’s something you love about where you live?
Andy Vargo [00:00:41]:
Well, I call Tacoma, Washington, home. It’s right here in the Pacific Northwest, and I am the ideal person to ask about it because I have lived here my whole life, and I absolutely just love Tacoma. Over everything, though. It’s really the community that’s here. You could go out to any part of town and people will say hi, and whether you’re in a bar or a coffee shop, meet strangers that are no longer strangers. And I just love that.
Amy Stone [00:01:06]:
I love that, too. I have been to Tacoma in my adventures in the Pacific Northwest. I think you guys have a pretty fantastic record store in Tacoma, like a vintage record store. And I bought a hat. Yes, that is what it is. High voltage. High voltage.
Andy Vargo [00:01:22]:
I was like, I hate to call out the wrong record store, but that’s a pretty popular one.
Amy Stone [00:01:25]:
That is the one. That is the one I found. So I have a trucker hat. I was so enamored with that. When I went in, I was like, I need to. I don’t need a record on my trip, but I will support this independent record store. So I love that.
Andy Vargo [00:01:37]:
All right.
Amy Stone [00:01:37]:
I love that. Very, very cool. Next. Get to know you question the way I ask people’s age without asking them their age. What generation descriptor matches you? Are you silent generation, Baby boomer, Gen X, millennial, or Gen Z?
Andy Vargo [00:01:52]:
I am Gen X.
Amy Stone [00:01:54]:
Me, too. Me too. It’s great.
Andy Vargo [00:01:56]:
The best generation.
Amy Stone [00:01:58]:
I mean, not to be too overly proud of ourselves, but yeah, for sure.
Speaker C [00:02:04]:
Right?
Amy Stone [00:02:04]:
Okay. So very, very good. So today we’re going to talk about identity, personal identity. And the reason we’re going to talk about this is because you shared with me, and this is the first time we’ve actually talked. So I don’t know you, like, a long time, but you shared with me that when you were 40, which is a big milestone age for all of us all the time, you. You made a change in your life. You came out of the closet. Now, I don’t know if there’s anybody on the interwebs who doesn’t know what we mean when we say came out these days. But for people who might be under a rock, this is when we tell the world about our sexual preferences. Right. That’s what we do. All right, very good. So one of the reasons that I think this might have been a big deal change for you is because at the time, I think that you had a spouse and a family. Is that right?
Andy Vargo [00:02:54]:
Correct? Yes. I’d been married for 20 years. Three kids.
Amy Stone [00:02:58]:
Very good. Three kids. How old were the kids when you were 40?
Andy Vargo [00:03:01]:
Then they were all teenagers from 14 to 19. So it was, you know, kind of a looking back, I was like, man, you know, if I could plan when to make things work well for raising kids, that might not have been the best time to have that realization. However, this is imperfect adulting.
Speaker C [00:03:20]:
Right.
Andy Vargo [00:03:21]:
And that was definitely imperfect timing. But it’s when things had to change.
Amy Stone [00:03:26]:
So, yeah, I mean, and that one of the reasons, like I use the word imperfect and I say to people, I’m like, it’s a starting point, right? It’s like releasing that idea that you’re ever going to hit that perfect timing for so many of these things. Right. So, all right, I’m going to ask you a couple of. I’m going to use your word, which is awkward. I’m going to use just some basic and old fashioned and honestly, slightly intrusive questions. So if I go too far, let me know. But I want to set the scene for people. There’s lots of people who’ve heard these stories and, you know, in 2026, we have a different relationship with, you know, the public awareness of LGBTQ scenarios, I feel like than in my childhood when I was young. You made this change in your life at age 40. But my question then is, is this when you discovered this for yourself about your sexuality, or is this something you had known about yourself and had obscured from the people around you?
Andy Vargo [00:04:23]:
Yeah, that’s such a great question. It’s one that people, it’s one of the first things people wonder. They think, right? People want to know, how did you not know? Did you just wake up one day and go, oh, I think this is how things are? And I knew from the earliest of ages that I was attracted to guys. I didn’t necessarily put that label on it. I remember even after I came out having a hard time saying I’m gay, because I would still say, well, I’m attracted to guys, because I didn’t see that as part of My identification, I was like, no, I’m not that. Like, I’m not. And it’s not to put anybody who identifies that way down. I just couldn’t relate to it in the early parts of my life. And I also, you know, growing up in a very Catholic family in the 80s and 90s, I didn’t see living that lifestyle as an option. And not even that I was yearning to live that life. It was more like, well, that’s not how you’re supposed to live. And I met someone in high school that I felt like I was in love with and felt like life is working and this is the way things are supposed to be. And maybe these are feelings everyone has and that’ll just go away as I age. And I, you know, I’m happy enough in this life. And so it wasn’t so much discovering it at 40, but really discovering that it’s not going to change and that I can’t be my best self, can’t be the best father if I can’t be honest with my kids. I can’t be a good husband if my spouse doesn’t even know me fully. I can’t show up anywhere in life completely if I’m not honest with myself first.
Amy Stone [00:06:02]:
Well, yeah, and we’re going to get more into that because that is the deeper layer of this conversation. So not everybody in the audience is going to have this kind of transformation where you’ve had. But the idea of like reconciling like your inner identity with the identity that you show to the world, this is something that everybody grapples with. It’s something that when you go back to the Psych 101, you know, coursework, it’s like, that was like, I think Carl Jung and Rogers, they’re both like talking about our sense of self and what we show to other people and all of those things. So you mentioned that you grew up in a faith based family, a Catholic family. And so was part of this that even though you felt a physical attraction to men that you did not have in your early years, any exposure to men who were romantically involved, like, it just was not something you had seen or had any awareness of?
Andy Vargo [00:07:05]:
No, not, not as a healthy situation.
Amy Stone [00:07:09]:
Okay.
Andy Vargo [00:07:09]:
There would be, you know, in culture you’d see kind of jokes or you know, what we would call now the meme where it’s like, oh, they’re, they’re a little different or I think they’re hanging out together. So there would be. And it’s not that I didn’t grow up in a hateful home where I heard a lot of. I never heard slurs or anything like that, but. But more so in culture, just around me, where you would kind of hear like, oh, yeah, I bet those guys are hanging out. You know, I don’t even remember some of the words, but awareness that there were gay people in the world, it’s not that I didn’t know that that wasn’t a thing, but it was also. I remember being in middle school, and I was younger than middle school, but I remember at one point asking my mom, there was some reference to Mary being the Virgin Mary. And. And I remember asking my mom, well, what does that mean to be a virgin? And I was young enough that my mom said, well, that means she’s never been with a man. Well, then when I get to middle school and people. Someone says, are you a virgin? And I’m like, well, of course I am. My thought was, I’ve never been with a man because that’s the way I interpreted that terminology. But I knew that that was not acceptable in society. So. Yeah, but to get to your question, yeah, there really. It’s not that I wasn’t aware there were gay people around, but it really. There was no example of.
Amy Stone [00:08:31]:
No example. And it sounds like if you. When you’re thinking back to your perception, it was a negative stereotype, like, this is not the way we have. This is not the way. You know, this is not the. This is not the good route to follow. So there was. It was discouraged. All right, so then. So did you marry your high school sweetheart? Then you met the person you married in high school?
Andy Vargo [00:08:54]:
All right, yeah, I got married. I was 21 when I got married. And, yeah, we’d been together for a few years before that.
Amy Stone [00:09:00]:
And you guys never. You never talked to her about the fact that you were attracted to men until. Until you were 40?
Andy Vargo [00:09:07]:
No, I was. That was my biggest fear was. Was being found out, that those were feelings that I had.
Amy Stone [00:09:15]:
Did you. Can I ask you, did you act on these while you. Like before you came out, did you. Did you explore these or. Because you were so young when you met the person you met?
Andy Vargo [00:09:23]:
No, I didn’t. And it was. It was more like when it was time to move on, it was more about. It was more about needing to move on because of all the other unhealthy dynamics in my life. And this was kind of at the crux of them, because.
Amy Stone [00:09:41]:
Tell me more, say more. So does that mean that because you were spending so much time masking and covering up and behaving in a way that wasn’t natural. You developed some things that were other unhealthy things.
Andy Vargo [00:09:54]:
Definitely. And really it wasn’t like I didn’t, I never ran into like addiction issues and things like that, that, like when we think about like unhealthy side of side, things that can happen. But I. I found myself continually putting myself in relationships where I was kind of the doormat. I wouldn’t stand up for myself. And I’ve. When I started to look the, the years leading up to when I made changes, I started paying better attention to the dynamics in the relationships in my life. But in a way where I started to ask myself, what’s the common denominator here? Why do I always end up working for a boss that is dominating and you know, saying things inappropriate or yelling? And I have a relationship with my spouse that is not healthy. It’s toxic. And at some point I have to say, well, how much have I taught people to, to treat me that way? Or how much have I either subconsciously sought out that dynamic or allowed it? And it’s not to say that those people are off the hook for their behavior. However, I allowed the behavior to continue because I wasn’t comfortable in my own skin. And I always had that fear of, well, if I stand up for myself, then what am I left with? Or I’d have the thought in the back of my head of, well, yeah, but I really am wrong because I’m not being honest here. So I’m. They’re not completely off that I’m shady or can’t be trusted, which is the, the dynamic I put on in my own head. It wasn’t the correct label to say that because I’m not comfortable my skin that it’s shady. But when people don’t know what we’re struggling with or what we’re hiding, all they feel is there’s something shady going on or you have an ulterior motive. And because they know they can’t trust you because you’re hiding something. And that’s my whole conversation now with people is us hiding who we are creates distrust. And if we can just be like, you know what? I feel self conscious right now cause I spilled mustard on my shirt. And so I’m trying to kind of hide myself now at least you know why I might be pulling back and it’s out on the table and we can move forward.
Amy Stone [00:12:02]:
Yeah, we’re going to talk more about that in a second because I think that’s a. I think that I Don’t think there’s anybody who makes it through a long life without grappling with that at different phases. It’s like, oh my gosh, if people look at me and they see me, they’re gonna see me. Oh, my gosh, what if they actually see me?
Andy Vargo [00:12:20]:
And I’m a big proponent of the fact my thing was that I was in the closet and that was what was hard for me to come to terms with. I’m not trying to say my struggle was so much worse and so much harder because that was the thing I was dealing with. We all have something and that’s. I really believe we don’t know what everybody’s thing is. That feels a little bit different, but we all have something.
Amy Stone [00:12:39]:
All right, so very good to change tactics, to change topics. Tiny bit or angles a tiny bit. I think that you and I are close in age, like within a decade, probably of each other. And so growing up in the 80s, right, the public image of LGBTQ individuals and couples and in media. Media and mainstream stuff, it’s more public and aware today than it was then. Like, there’s examples and all kind of magazines and so on. So anyway, this is an opinion. Like, I’m not setting you up to be an expert on this, but do you think that younger humans today, so like people who are in middle school today, even if they’re in a faith based family or a small town, do you think that they have a different experience dealing with this sort of teen identity exploration at different pressures, good, bad, and all the others? Because it is. There’s a lot more public representation.
Andy Vargo [00:13:42]:
I would say that’s a fair statement. I remember even before I came out, one of my sons was talking about a friend that was in their friends group. And this was when they were, you know, probably 14 or 15 years old at the time. And he said, yeah, you know, he doesn’t know if he’s gay yet. He’s still trying to figure it out. And he was saying it just as a no big deal. I don’t even know why it came up, but I thought how cool. I wish that was the sentiment when I was that age where it was like, oh, yeah, we just. We don’t know if, you know, Andy’s figuring himself out yet or not, but we’re here when he does and it doesn’t matter which way he goes. The that was not. And maybe, maybe my friends that. That I was around might have felt that way, but I didn’t dare risk asking. And so I think that the openness around the conversation is a lot healthier in that way. I think that also, really. Well, as a whole, it’s better. There’s still places where, you know, it depends on the. The very few people you’re surrounded by in your inner circle.
Amy Stone [00:14:48]:
Oh, I think that’s a really good point of context. Like, it doesn’t matter quite as much what’s happening on Instagram, TikTok or, you know, a broadcast media channel. It also matters what’s happening in your very private universe, your very immediate universe. Not necessarily private, but you’re very immediate, social. That’s a very important thing. All right, so if your life were a Hollywood movie, then when you came out at 40, rainbows and unicorns would have showered from the sky and things would have been all immediately blissful. But I don’t think, based on the little I know of your story, I don’t think that’s exactly how it turns out. I think that you mentioned that you lost the job and there were some other challenges. So was the job loss related to making this announcement? Like, let’s talk about some of these challenges?
Andy Vargo [00:15:36]:
Well, it wasn’t said that way, but it was three weeks after I came out and I was let go for not being able to keep up with an area, a territory.
Amy Stone [00:15:46]:
Okay.
Andy Vargo [00:15:47]:
And had been not given help when I had asked for it. And then later, you know, the three people were hired to replace the work I was doing. So just reading between the lines, I think, yeah, you know, maybe there was something there. I try not to get caught up in assuming other people’s motives. Although looking back, I think that timing is a little bit suspicious, so. And I did actually talk to, you
Amy Stone [00:16:14]:
know, like, to making yourself feel bad. Like the impact is the impact even.
Andy Vargo [00:16:19]:
Yeah, yeah, right. And, and, and realistically, I know I wasn’t keeping up well. I was in the middle of a divorce. I was. I know that there were things where I was not struggling with and at that time in my life, who I was then, I was not the best at saying, this is not sustainable. This is not fair. We need to fix this. I would not have. I would not have voiced it as well as I would now. And so I can see where I didn’t do myself any favors in kind of raising the hand and saying, this needs to be fixed. However, it seems like that was kind of obvious. But. But also looking back is like, I remember losing that job and thinking, I don’t know if I even want that job. It’s like, I’m ready to move on. And it was Kind of the last casualty of other changes I was making in life. And I remember after, like, when you mentioned the rainbow bows and unicorns popping out of the sky and balloons everywhere. And I remember getting several months after into life changes, being out renting a room, being very alone, not living with your kids, and just sitting in this space of going, what was all this for? What was the point of making all these major changes just over, like, who you want to have sex with? Like, why is that? Like, that seems, like, so unimportant compared to all of the things that were rocked in my life. Now when we make big changes, you know, there’s the hills and valleys, and we get to the valleys before we start to get up to the summit where we start to see the view change. And I just remember sitting in that space thinking, I don’t know if this was worth it, and really struggling with the fact that this was supposed to be a good change and it didn’t feel like it. But that’s because everything had been stripped away. That was my regular support system, my financial support. Everything had been. Was gone. And yet I hadn’t started to refill the cup yet. So until I was able to take other action that then rebuilt myself, like, I didn’t understand that as part of the process, I was like, man, I thought there were gonna be rainbows and unicorns. And I’m just sitting here alone in my room, you know, crying my eyes out. Like, what is this one of the.
Amy Stone [00:18:45]:
So Martha Beck, who is a life coach, she describes that sensation as the empty elevator. Like, you’re making change in your life, and so you get on the elevator of personal change. It’s not. This metaphor is not perfect, in my opinion, but, like. But the empty elevator sensation, you know, is, I think, one that we’ve all felt like. It’s like, no one is in there with me. Like, you’re in with a lot of people, and then all of a sudden, it’s empty. And just like, what you’re saying, it’s like, because you haven’t refilled it. You haven’t. You haven’t done those things. So. Yeah. So then was it a. Was it a surprise? So there’s some pretty major changes. This ends your marriage, and it changes your living situation. And so was this a very big surprise and a really tough thing for your wife and your children for a long time? A short time? Never at all. Like, how was this met within your personal support group and family? Because it sounds like your family is very important to you.
Andy Vargo [00:19:48]:
Yeah. It was definitely a long adjustment and I think there are, there are different. The thing that I found interesting is that it was definitely a surprise to my ex wife. That’s, that’s her new preferred pronoun, by the way. But we, I found that the, the initial part was, okay, now things make sense and this is why we were not always lined up. And so then there was actually a time where things made more sense and we got along okay. And then a little bit afterwards when I started to unpack and realize the dynamics of things that were not healthy in our relationship and stand up for myself in different ways, then that kind of shifted the dynamic of conversations because it wasn’t so much, oh, you’re gay and that’s a problem. It’s, oh, I can’t treat you the same way because you don’t accept it or allow it in your life. Now we don’t have that same relationship.
Amy Stone [00:20:50]:
So, so then initially, did you just come to your wife with the, this is the thing about me that’s going on and where you’re not sure how it would impact the family. Was there a piece of you that thought, well, maybe I can just be more me and the family will stay the way it is?
Andy Vargo [00:21:05]:
Well, to be really frank, the relationship was pretty bad. For years we’ve been talking about divorce and I knew that it was not, I didn’t, I did not feel good in the relationship myself. And there were things that I didn’t stand up for myself about. And I remember this, and this is, I felt like a chicken way to do it. Cause honestly, people are like, that’s so brave that you came out. And I’m like, no, it was actually easier to say I’m gay than to say this is an unhealthy dynamic and you don’t treat me well and I deserve better. That took too much guts. To me, this was the chicken way out. To just be like, well, this is something you can’t argue with. I know that’s just the wrong answer, but it is very much it was the right answer in the long term. Once I came to terms with everything. However, there was just a point where we had had a really bad weekend and you know, she was blowing me off and we were on a walk and just driving home from this walk having a very non emotional conversation about divorce. It was very much, well, what if we do this, what if we do that? It wasn’t a fight, it was, how do we make this work for our kids so that we can not be fighting all the time? And move on. And then four weeks later, we had a really good weekend. And I just remember at the end of the weekend, she’s looking at me like, oh, this is great. Things are going to work. And I was like, I thought I had a way out. I thought we were done. I thought we were moving on. And so I just remember saying, if we’re going to try to make this work, you need to know this about me again, because I didn’t have the guts to say, I want to move on. I’m not happy in this situation because I was too chicken that I put it on someone else to say, well, if we want to make this work, you’ve got to know this. Take it or leave it. Like, that’s not the right way to stand up for yourself in a relationship or to declare what you want. I’m fully aware of that now. This is after a decade of work, by the way. I can have these conversations now with the reflection of, yeah, I wouldn’t handle that the same way today. But I can also acknowledge that that’s the tools that I had to work with and where I was in the time
Amy Stone [00:23:25]:
when you made the announcement and you said, listen, if we’re going to have any more of these conversations, there’s something you need to know about me. This is how I’m actually attracted to men. Was that an instant grenade in the marriage where you were very quickly looking for a new place to live and doing the details, or was it like a we’ll talk about it tomorrow kind of conversation?
Andy Vargo [00:23:50]:
It was a back and forth. I mean, there was probably. There was a few weeks before I actually moved out. It was like, you know, do we try to make this work? Do we not? The initial was kind of like the end of a Sally field movie, like Mrs. Doubtfare, where it’s like the whole time, oh, my God. The whole. The whole. Like, how could I not know?
Amy Stone [00:24:08]:
Yes. Yeah.
Andy Vargo [00:24:09]:
Yeah. And so. But yeah, but there was a, you know, do we make this work? Do we not? Clearly it’s not going to work because, you know, there’s. When you are. The complication with a marriage is that. And this is what I felt leading up to the several years before thinking, man, I don’t know that I can keep moving on. Like, this was. Is. You have these thoughts of, it’s not just my life I’m affecting. And it seems very selfish to make this statement. And yet it’s actually selfish to try to keep everything together without giving everyone else the chance to be part of the decision. And I couldn’t show up as the best father or the best spouse if I wasn’t my full self and couldn’t actually let people know who I was because I couldn’t answer a question completely honestly without having to sit back and think, well, how is this going to impact the way they might view me or think of me? Instead of just saying, well, this is what I think. And so, yeah, so that time leading up to it, you know, when there’s something in a marriage that shifts the dynamic of the relationship between the two people, those two people also have to consider, how does this affect our kids? Can we each be okay alone, even financially? It’s not a simple, it’s not, you know, it’s not a simple shift where we say, okay, I’m moving on, because I don’t accept this piece that you just added to the equation. It’s okay. Yes. I don’t like that piece of the equation, however. How much do we want to disrupt the life of our kids? How much do we want to, Can I even afford a place on my own? How does all of that look? And so that initial transition is very much figuring things out and then you figure things out and then you’re out on your own going, man, why did I do that?
Amy Stone [00:26:03]:
Yeah, it’s a big disruption that is definitely, regardless of the reason for disassembling, decoupling a family is. It’s definitely part of the transition that shows up all the time. It also shows up in, it’s really interesting. So in research it shows up when people are widowed, but that has a completely different social dynamic than divorce. So there’s like tons of community support for widows in most cases. But divorce, people always talk about feeling isolated and, you know, alone. So for you though, I think you’re going through like a get to know yourself as a result of this. So you talk about how, you talked about how this is allowing you to live authentically. And it sounds like, you know, you made this announcement, but you’d never had a chance to sort of live this as your identity. So you were getting to know yourself within that like sort of self help coaching space. We use the word authenticity like so much. It’s a real buzzword. Right. And yet I wanted to talk to you about it and give you a chance to talk about it because I think it can be confusing when you’re in a situation where you have been disconnected from a part of your personality for whatever reason, or in your case, masking or repressing a piece of who you are.
Speaker C [00:27:27]:
Right.
Amy Stone [00:27:28]:
To even know what that authenticity is or what it would feel like or how to lean into it kind of thing.
Speaker C [00:27:36]:
Like, it’s like.
Amy Stone [00:27:36]:
So I wanted to give you a chance to talk more how that felt, to be connecting with your authentic self as a part of this transition.
Andy Vargo [00:27:47]:
Oh, I appreciate that. It’s interesting. When we develop a set of coping mechanisms for our entire life, we don’t realize how many things we’re doing just subconsciously. And without even giving thought to it, I know that we. When I was in the closet, I would think about every step of the day, you know, how do I. How am I going to dress? Because I don’t want to look too stylish, because that’s going to look gay. What am I going to order for lunch? If I go out with coworkers? I don’t want to get a salad, because that’s going to look gay. And I know these are all stereotypes, but that’s the danger of what we allow to live in our head. It’s that every single decision. I would be afraid when people would ask, like, what my favorite music was, I wouldn’t want to replace reply, because I didn’t want to. I didn’t know what the right answer was. I was always caught up with what the right answer was. And so when we start to make these changes, I had to actually start acknowledging that I was still struggling with showing up and being myself, because I still had that innate urge to just step back and say, okay, but what’s the right thing? I was talking to a friend about a year after I came out, and I said something about, oh, well, that’s gonna make me look gay, or they’re gonna know I’m gay. And he just said. He kind of laughed, and he’s like, but you are. And I was like, oh, you’re right. Like, it isn’t a problem that I look that way because that’s who I am. And it’s not that. The other thing is, I don’t want. It’s funny because, yes, I signed up for this podcast to talk about this part of my life, but I also don’t want it to be that people meet me and go, oh, that’s gay, Andy. Or that’s like, I don’t. That doesn’t need to be the full identity of who I am. And that was, I think, another fear is that being authentic and leaning into one part of our life doesn’t mean it has to take over your entire life. There are people who meet me, who know me for a long Time and don’t even know that side of me. And it’s not because I’m hiding it anymore. It’s because no conversation came up where it was relevant. You know, we met as small business owners, or we met because they’re the barista at my coffee shop, and I go in there every day, and then one day they’re like, oh, I didn’t know that about you. And it’s not a big deal. It’s just. Yeah, because I was giving you my coffee order. I was asking how your kids are. Right, right.
Amy Stone [00:30:10]:
You don’t have to be like, you’re. This part of your identity does not need to be the main focus of your. Of anything, unless it relates. And it is. No, I think that’s absolutely true. And I think that when I talk to people about transitions and specifically titles.
Speaker C [00:30:31]:
Right.
Amy Stone [00:30:31]:
Because anytime you go through a transition, if your title changes, like, you know, employee to retiree, you know.
Andy Vargo [00:30:40]:
Yeah.
Amy Stone [00:30:41]:
Female to mom or stepmom. Right. You know, dad to, you know, husband, ex husband.
Speaker C [00:30:47]:
Right.
Amy Stone [00:30:47]:
That’s the. You know, any of those things. Sometimes there can be a lot of resistance to that new title. And the example you gave is exactly what I do. I’m like, you want to get to the point where, you know, it’s aligned enough. When I know that I’m aligned is when somebody comes up and they’re like, oh, well, you’re Amy. And I’m like, yes, I know. Like, it’s not like, you know, it’s not like a challenge. It’s like. It’s like. And what.
Andy Vargo [00:31:11]:
You know, like, and where are we going with this?
Amy Stone [00:31:15]:
Yes. You know, and when I was in my early 20s, I did a year of study abroad, and one of the people in the cohort was very focused on the fact that we needed to dress in this European fashion or else people would know that we were Americans. And I remember she was very enthusiastic, delightful person. I tell this story all the time. And I remember that, like, after several days of this, I was like, I am American. They are going to know as soon as I open my mouth. Like, I’m not sure I fully understand why I’m supposed to be hiding this. Like, I’m not going to do a good job of obscuring this. Even if I dress perfectly, the minute I say one thing, they’re going to know.
Andy Vargo [00:31:48]:
I’m gonna open my mouth. They’re gonna know.
Amy Stone [00:31:50]:
They’re going to know. And so for me, while she really enjoyed that and she went on to do that, for me, it was like, I’m just gonna embrace the fact that I am an American in this spot, which I think that that coming. And I think it’s probably different for everybody. But I think that like you said, you were looking for the type of authenticity where you were not having to spend a lot of time planning and worrying about how people would based on how you showed up.
Andy Vargo [00:32:18]:
Yeah. And definitely once I realized how much I was doing it, I think that awareness then helped me to think, okay, I don’t need to stew on every decision. And I, you know, I can pick and choose the important ones that require more thought. But.
Amy Stone [00:32:36]:
And when you say that, does that we’re not aware, like, because that’s, you know, that’s the other word, clarity that we throw around all the time. But it’s like when you’re not aware you’re doing something, you’re not aware, you’re unclear.
Andy Vargo [00:32:48]:
Right, exactly. And even just people would be like, where do you want to go for lunch? And I’d be like, I really struggle answering that question. And now I’ll say, you know, pizza or Mexican or Chinese, I don’t care. Or I’ll say, hey, I’ve honored to try this new place. But if you have something else in mind, great, because I honestly don’t sometimes care. But breaking down the difference between do I really not have a stake in the decision or do I struggle to make a claim on what it is that I care about? And those are two different things. And I think breaking that apart so that I can have that clarity around, am I struggling to make a decision or do I really not have any care in that process?
Amy Stone [00:33:30]:
So when I hear you say that, I’m going to ask this follow up question then. Was making decisions harder for you when you had all of this brain chatter in your mind, like, did. Did making good decisions become easier with authenticity in your life?
Andy Vargo [00:33:48]:
Oh, definitely, yes.
Amy Stone [00:33:50]:
Makes sense.
Andy Vargo [00:33:50]:
I could go on about that, but it’s, it’s an easy. Yes, definitely.
Amy Stone [00:33:54]:
Well, I think that that’s helpful for people. I’ve heard that come up in many stories of people’s lived experience. And it’s one of the reasons that I like to tell stories of, you know, people’s lived experience. Because, you know, in a textbook, you know, it’s like, just make a decision, just make a decision quickly. But, you know, sometimes when we’re struggling to make a decision, it might be helpful to be like, why? Why is decision making, you know, hard? And I don’t know that we can always see that until we’re through on the other side to tell you.
Andy Vargo [00:34:22]:
Right. And one thing that I’ve. I’ve been able to look back and noticed is that when I was spending all day long thinking about how I was showing up and being preoccupied with that I can’t even put a guesstimate on, was that 30% of my headspace? Was it 40%? Was it 60%? But it was a huge amount of my thoughts and headspace and being preoccupied with how I’m showing up. So that means that only leaves the rest for me to make a clear decision with. So I think I’m showing up 100% or 120% because it feels like I’m working so hard, and yet I really only have 60% effort or attention to devote.
Amy Stone [00:35:03]:
That’s a really good point. That’s a really good point. All right, so one of the questions that I ask people pretty frequently nowadays on this show is because people show up and they tell personal stories, right? Like you were saying 98% of your life, probably this story is not relevant to the actual exchange. When you go into sweetgreen to order a salad, they don’t need to know. They don’t need to know. So then the question is, though, why is this a story that you want to share? Who do you hope hears it? And what is the benefit that you hope that people who are watching and listening get from hearing your story of making this change in your life?
Andy Vargo [00:35:45]:
I think what it really comes down to for me is that we all have something we feel insecure, uncomfortable about. And if someone like, I don’t expect everyone to go, oh, yeah, I’m gonna go. Come out of the closet tomorrow. Like, I know that most of the world is not gay. I’m not expect. I’m not out here to convert people to, you know, my gay religion or anything, but it really is that I want to convert you to say, you know, if I’ve been holding back on the fact that I love pineapple on pizza, and I haven’t wanted to voice that in the office because I know that there are pineapple pizza haters that I’m surrounded by, I’m gonna be okay saying I like it. And that’s okay, because that’s gonna open up the doors for me to not only repel the people that have that problem with me, but also attract the people who are gonna support that part of my life. You know, you could be sitting in a coffee shop and you see someone knitting, and, you know, if we didn’t have the courage to do that publicly, in front of other people. That person is gonna have some people say, oh, my gosh, they got to take their yarn everywhere. I can’t stand yarn. Makes me feel itchy. Whatever. But you’re going to have even more people who come up to you and say, wow, what are you knitting? I just started knitting. And you’re probably sitting there going, I’m knitting because I’m an introvert. Please don’t talk to me. Whatever. The thing is, it’s going to allow you to find the right support, and it’s going to just. It just makes life easier because we stop wasting time with all the things that actually don’t matter to us.
Amy Stone [00:37:12]:
Yeah, the support pieces actually can be, you know, used the example of, like, knitting in a social circle, which is good, but it. It’s actually. I mean, it touches everything. So it’s like if you. If you live in a family or a dorm or a group house where everybody listens to country music and you, you know, you don’t tell people that you like alternative, they will probably assume that you like country and you’ll be uncomfortable. And nobody even knows, right? Nobody even knows. And so they can’t, you know, they just assume you’re along for the ride, and so you feel isolated and unsupported. And if you put that in, you know, there are some things like. That are. One of the early interviews I did, more than a decade ago, I interviewed a man who has had dwarfism. And he. One of the things he pointed out is he can’t hide his difference. And he talked about how that, you know, that had its benefits and its. And its shortcomings.
Andy Vargo [00:38:07]:
Right.
Amy Stone [00:38:07]:
But. So he can’t obscure it. He has to deal with the fact that people see it and can make that decision. And so it’s in the face, you know, people know. And. But on the flip side, if it’s something invisible and you don’t tell people, they can’t help you and they can’t support you, you know, so they can’t give you directions, you know, they can’t. Nothing. They can’t. Nothing. And so it just fawns out on all those things. All right, so very good. So thank you for answering that. So today I believe that you are a speaker and an author and a coach, and people can find yo*@***********er.com is that right?
Andy Vargo [00:38:42]:
Correct. Yes.
Amy Stone [00:38:43]:
Awkwardcareer.com you have a podcast which is Own youn Awkward. And so those are the things. And you have a free download that people in the audience can get from the show notes on the audio player or in YouTube called Discover your hidden superpower. So all of that information is in those places, the show notes and on YouTube and those things like that. I always remind people, people, the easiest way to get the links, especially for the free stuff, is to subscribe to the email co*******@***************ng.com because then I zap it into your email box and you can click on it straight. That way it’s very easy. You ready to wrap this up with my final random questions? They’re no longer random actually, but all right, here we go. So if you can share something right today, you know, there’s no shortage of information. We can find anything at our fingertips. We just speak our desires into the air and we begin to get served. Social media ads for the things that we don’t want but share with us. Personal referrals are a great thing. Share with us something good that you like that you think other people would enjoy a referral. It could be a great movie, TV show, wonderful book, something that you’ve enjoyed that you think the audience would like.
Andy Vargo [00:39:54]:
Oh my gosh, again. See, I have such a hard time picking a favorite. It’s one of those things I’ve realized and I knew that these form of these questions were coming because I’ve enjoyed listening to your show. You know, lately I’ve, I just took the, this is just top of mind because a friend of mine is a neuroscientist, Melissa Hughes, and she created this, this cognitive blueprint assessment and it’s at brain power rocks. And you can, you can learn how your brain actually works in default. And I just, I took this test and it was such an eye opening thing because there were moments where I look back at my life went, oh, that’s why my brain works that way. Or that’s why I want to do this thing. But she does these neuro nuggets and I’ve just been all over watching her stuff because every time I watch one I just, I’m enthralled. But it’s Melissa Hughes. Take the cognitive blueprint. It’s, you don’t even have to, you don’t even have to give her your email to get the result and you don’t have to pay to get the good results, so. Cause a lot of times we worry about that, like, what am I signing up for?
Amy Stone [00:40:56]:
Oh yeah, you can just go in there. Is it going? Yes, exactly like, like, yeah, exactly. All of the like fitness things. All of the things it’s like now just 24.99 to get your custom plan. It was like. That was not the ad. That was not the ad.
Andy Vargo [00:41:08]:
Exactly.
Amy Stone [00:41:09]:
Yeah, absolutely. That’s. Okay. So, Melissa Hughes, brain power rocks. That’s a wonderful suggestion. I appreciate that. And I love that you’re learning that about you. Okay. This is a segment of the show that I am now calling Unsupervised Online Shopping. What is something that you have purchased online for yourself that you are really pretty sure was pretty great, and you think that everybody should know about it?
Andy Vargo [00:41:32]:
Okay, so I’m just a geek about doing all my business stuff, and I don’t do a lot of online shopping, but when I do, it’s usually for my business. But the latest thing that I bought was the little microphone that you plug into your phone so you can record. And it just makes a difference because I can have my phone across the trail and I can be coming out of the bushes and you can still hear me. It’s kind of creepy because. Can you. My voice should be further away from the camera. But I’m all about, you know, when you’re. When you make your business your life, there’s such a line as I’m sure you know, it’s like, oh, this is what I do. I guess something more fun was I did get some foldable kayaks a couple years ago. Those. Those were more fun. That’s what I should have led with, was the foldable kayaks.
Amy Stone [00:42:14]:
No, I think that the. I think that the, you know, the little. The camera mics, the phone mics. I mean, I have one of those, too. So do you do some like you do when you’re out hiking? You do, like, videos and you set your phone.
Andy Vargo [00:42:25]:
Yeah, I’ll do quirky little reels or thoughts in time. You know, any. Any little. Whatever random thought pops into my head. I’ll. I’ll make a video and put it out there. Some of them are funny, some are entertaining, some are really inspirational, and some are like, why did you even make that?
Amy Stone [00:42:40]:
So I love. I mean, I have one of those, too, and I love it. I don’t use it as much as I could. And then I. Bizarrely, because I’m old, I have, like, a pet peeve, which is like, I don’t like it when people hold those little microphones in their finger.
Andy Vargo [00:42:49]:
It’s the same way. Or put it on a pencil.
Speaker C [00:42:52]:
I actually.
Amy Stone [00:42:52]:
That I don’t mind, like, the guys who clip it onto, like, a spatula. I’m like, that. I get. I totally get. But the ones where they’re holding it right here or they’re doing an interview and they’re passing it back and forth for some reason. That drives me bananas. It doesn’t bother most people and it’s not a thing that I should spend any of my time worrying about, but it totally is. All right. So that is very foldable kayaks, though. Very cool. Very, very cool. That’s it. Andy Vago, thank you so much for being a wonderful guest today on the show.
Andy Vargo [00:43:19]:
Amy, thank you so much. It was such a pleasure to be here.
Amy Stone [00:43:23]:
Thank you for joining me today. I hope you enjoyed the show.
Speaker C [00:43:27]:
Before I go, I want to encourage you to become a bigger part of the conversation. Please subscribe wherever you’re listening or watching the show. That helps my stats. A request from the bottom of my indie creator heart is to please tell your friends about the show. That is the real way new people discover it.
Amy Stone [00:43:46]:
If you feel motivated, I would love
Speaker C [00:43:48]:
it if you rated the show or wrote a review on whatever platform you are using. Please be sure to head over to ImperfectAdulting.com and sign up for the email community. I call this the Village. You’ll get some free stuff right away and you’ll begin to get the weekly emails that I send. This includes the links for special offer offers from any guests on the show and cool stuff I put together for the community. There’s a lot more going on than
Amy Stone [00:44:16]:
just this show and the only way
Speaker C [00:44:17]:
to find out is to get the emails. Plus, you’re busy. You don’t have time or desire to follow every single tidbit on social media. And you don’t have to because I’m
Amy Stone [00:44:27]:
happy to send it to you if you have a story you’d like to
Speaker C [00:44:30]:
share with the audience. I have an open application for guests. Guess where you’ll find it? That’s right, on the website and in the emails. And that’s a wrap for this episode until next time. Remember that the journey is the destination. Ralph Waldo Emerson said that, not me. Well, until just now I did just say it. But what I want you to hear today is that if your adulting journey isn’t going the way you expected, that just may not mean you’re lost. It may mean that you’re just on your way.
Amy Stone [00:44:58]:
And now the fine print the Art
Speaker C [00:45:01]:
of Imperfect Adulting podcast and streaming video show is a copyrighted work created and produced by Amy Stone and Amy says so. The music was written and produced by Todd Thompson at Dharma Bomb Studios. All rights are reserved. Anything expressed on this show is offered as entertainment and the views of the guests may not always represent the ideas and viewpoints of the host. That’s me. Amy Stone does not intend to hold myself, herself out to provide professional advice or recommendations of any kind. In the end, you and you alone need to make those kinds of decisions based on your personal and individual situation, needs, circumstances and comfort level. Yeah, it’s a little weird for me to talk about myself in the third person, but you get the idea. This is Amy Stone signing off.

